Need help getting your new baby to sleep?
Check out our Born To Sleep Newborn Sleep Course!

Five Reasons Your Baby Won’t Sleep in the Crib and How to Respond

Baby sleeping peacefully after resolving issues that prevent them from sleeping in a crib.

So, you’ve got this picture-perfect crib, complete with those adorable duck-print sheets, but your baby seems to have other ideas about sleep. If your little one treats the crib like a no-sleep zone, you’re definitely not alone. Many parents face this head-scratcher: why does my baby refuse to sleep in what I’ve so lovingly prepared?

Whether it’s a sudden crib boycott or a long-standing rebellion, we get it. It’s both baffling and exhausting. Here’s what we’ll cover to help you out:

  • Seven key reasons why babies resist sleeping in their cribs.
  • Tailored solutions for each specific reason.
  • General advice for easing the crib transition.

Let’s delve into what’s going on and find some practical, real-world solutions to coax your baby into embracing their crib. We’ll look at understanding your baby’s unique sleep needs and share tips that have worked for many weary parents like you. Here’s to hoping for more zzz’s for both you and your baby soon.

Baby Won’t Sleep in Crib Due to Separation Anxiety

Whether it’s the first time or the hundredth time you’ve put your baby down for the night, the onset of separation anxiety around the eight-month mark can lead to tears and resistance. It’s a normal developmental stage, signaling they’re beginning to understand the concept of permanence—that you exist even when out of sight. It’s a sign of healthy attachment but knowing that doesn’t necessarily make bedtime any easier.

Solution: Build confidence and comfort

A consistent routine is your best friend. A familiar series of steps leading up to bedtime can be immensely comforting for a baby dealing with separation anxiety. Introduce a special ‘goodnight’ toy that stays in the crib, something they associate with sleep time and your presence. Practice brief, soothing separations throughout the day, so they learn you always return. And when it’s time to say goodnight, keep your departure calm and confident. With time, your little one will learn that their crib is a safe place and that you’re just around the corner.

Overstimulation Prevents Baby from Sleeping in the Crib

Too much stimulation before bedtime can make it tough for your baby to settle down in their crib. Bright lights, loud noises, or even an overly busy room can keep their little minds buzzing. It’s like trying to sleep in the middle of a musical light show — not exactly conducive to rest.

Solution: Establishing a sensory-smart, safe sleep environment

To create a more soothing atmosphere, start with blackout curtains to keep the room dark and calm. A white noise machine can work wonders, providing a steady, soothing sound that helps drown out any disruptive background noise. Keep the temperature comfortable — not too hot, not too cold.

An important reminder: a safe crib is a sparse crib. Aside from a fitted sheet, the crib should be free of toys, pillows, and loose bedding to ensure a safe sleeping environment. In addition to ensuring safety, this setup minimizes overstimulation; and it’ll signal to your baby that it’s time to wind down and rest.

Discomfort or Illness Disrupting Sleep

Physical discomfort can disrupt anyone’s sleep, especially a baby’s. Whether it’s feeding issues, teething, or a cold, these discomforts can make the crib seem like the least inviting place on earth.

Solution: Tend to physical needs before bedtime

To ensure your baby’s crib feels like a haven, tackle the basics: feed them, change them, and dress them in comfortable, temperature-appropriate clothing. If teething is turning nights into a nightmare, a gentle gum massage or a pediatrician-recommended pain reliever might be in order. By addressing these fundamental needs, you’re not only ensuring your baby’s comfort but also fostering a sleep environment that’s as inviting as it is restful – all without falling into the trap of temporary fixes that could lead to longer-term sleep dependencies. 

Inconsistent Sleep Routines

Whether due to holidays, family visits, or just a change in the usual schedule, inconsistencies in a baby’s sleep routine can unsettle even the best of sleepers. Just like us, babies rely on certain signals to tell them when it’s time to wind down. The lack of a regular bedtime routine can make it hard for them to understand that it’s time for sleep, especially if they’re in a different environment.

Solution: Sticking to the script

The key to navigating these changes is to maintain the bedtime ritual as closely as possible. If you read a story, sing a lullaby, and dim the lights at home, do your best to replicate this sequence wherever you are. Sure, there will be times when flexibility is necessary—like that late-night family dinner or the unavoidable jet lag. When these disruptions happen, it’s important to return to the regular routine as swiftly as possible afterward. This consistency provides a sense of security and makes it clear that, despite the day’s changes, bedtime still means sleep time.

Sleep Props and Their Pitfalls for Independent Sleep

Sleep associations, also known as props, are the routines and items that your baby associates with the process of falling asleep. They can be deeply ingrained, and when absent, may prevent your baby from settling. For adults, it’s akin to needing complete darkness or silence to drift off. For babies, it might be the motion of a car ride, rocking in a parent’s arms, the comfort of nursing, or even the simple act of sucking on a pacifier. If these conditions change mid-sleep — like the car stopping or the pacifier falling out — your baby might find it as jarring as you would if you fell asleep under a cozy duvet and woke to find it gone.

Solution: Establishing independent sleep

To foster healthier sleep habits, it’s essential to encourage associations that don’t rely on specific conditions. This means putting your baby into their crib when they’re drowsy but awake, allowing them to associate the crib with the act of falling asleep. Separating feeding from sleeping and easing out of habits like rocking or holding to sleep can make a big difference. Avoid introducing new props to manage temporary changes; instead, aim for a consistent bedtime routine that your baby can count on, night after night. This consistency helps your baby learn to self-soothe and fall asleep independently, leading to more restful nights for everyone.

Crib Success Awaits

Navigating the crib conundrum can be a journey, but you’re now equipped with strategies to make it smoother. With an understanding of what might be disrupting your baby’s sleep and how to address it, you’re on the path to more peaceful nights. Remember, consistency is comforting, and a crib can be a cozy retreat with the right approach. Here’s to restful slumbers and the sweetest of dreams for your little one.

Book Your FREE 20-Minute
"Let's Get Acquainted" Call

Our Sleep Coach Team would like to know what you or your baby/child are struggling with so let’s chat! 

Our team wants to help your family get peaceful nights and calmer naps!

Sleep Sense - Tender Transition
Top Sleep Consultant Badge - Tender Transitions
Doula - Tender Transition
Certified Lactation Counselor - Tender Transition
Book about sleep - Tender Transitions

FREE Download!

The Five Steps to Getting Your Child to Sleep Through the Night!

We hate spam as much as you do and will NEVER share your info but we will share some monthly tips.

Tender Transition
Contact Us:
Scroll to Top